Review: Battle Royale by Koushun Takami

Battle Royale by Koushun Takami

Final Verdict: 3.25 out of 4.0

YTD: 25


Plot/Story:
3 – Plot/Story is interesting & believable.

Every year, in the Republic of East Asia, one 3rd-year Junior High class, made up of 15-year olds, is selected at random to participate in a Battle Royal – an epic fight to the death, where the final student to survive is crowned the winner.  The rationale for this yearly “program” is that the totalitarian government uses the events as a learning exercise for their military but, in reality, it is simply a way of generating fear and total devotion to the government.  The kids believe they are on a school trip, but as they are journeying via bus, a sleeping agent is released and everyone wakes up inside a classroom, where they discover they have been collared with an electronic device which not only monitors their whereabouts but will also explode if they try to escape or are caught in certain “forbidden zones” on the island where they have been relocated. The kids each get one bag of supplies, including one random weapon (ranging from simple instruments like a sharp stick or ice pick, to hand grenades and even a machine gun).  Suddenly, these classmates and friends are pitted against each other – some become killers out of fear, some because they were destined to be all along, and others only take lives while trying to save their own. 


Characterization:
3 – Characters well-developed.

There is a wide range of characters in this story, which is necessary with a cast of more than 40 people (42 students, initially, plus their schoolmaster, the game director, security guards, parents, etc.).  While there is a lack of depth in the more “evil” of characters (those like Kazuo and Mitsuko who are soulless and violent for the sake of being violent), there are certain characters who are truly interesting to watch, and who the reader might root for, such as Shinji, the sweet and brilliant computer nerd who has a plan to escape, and Shogo, the boy who seems a bit older than the rest and who has incredible secrets.  The two main characters, Noriko and Shuya, develop well over the course of the story – they grow somewhat as individuals and also as a couple (and, with Shogo, as a team).  The varied responses and ways of “playing the game” are reflected well in the diverse types of personalities present in this group of school kids, which makes a sometimes unbelievable plot feel more realistic and natural. 


Prose/Style:
3 – Satisfactory Prose/Style, conducive to the Story.

The story reads somewhat like an action movie-meets manga/graphic novel.  It is, at times, ridiculously over-the-top and cheesy.  Some of the dialogue, particularly the internal dialogue, is silly and very much “Japanese Pop” in nature.  The dialogue felt, at times, stiff, unnatural, and not at all in keeping with the age level of these kids or with the nature of the story which is quite dark, but which sometimes feels self-parodied (as if the writer sometimes felt self-conscious about his own seriousness, or lack thereof). Still, the book is appropriately fast-paced and the breaking up of chapters to focus on different characters is interesting in that it allows the reader an inside-look at everyone involved.  Keeping the book narrated in the third-person also means that the reader does not need to rely too heavily on a possibly flawed narrator.  The book’s structure might be its greatest achievement, as it is extremely difficult to care about characters in a book whose point-of-view, so to speak, changes on a constant basis.  There was some choppiness and grammar/spelling errors due, in part, to the translation – but which should have been caught and corrected during the editing process. 


Additional Elements: Setting, Symbols/Motifs, Resolution, etc.
4 – Additional elements improve and advance the story.

First of all, it must be said that the similarities between this book and The Hunger Games trilogy by Suzanne Collins (which came after Battle Royale) are prevalent enough that it would be irresponsible to ignore them.  From the premise itself, to the idea of trackers, from the importance of the bird call to the inclusion of “bags of supplies” for the contestants, from betting on winners to televising the results, from manipulating the game to discourage participants from being idle to awarding the winner a lifetime pension and national fame, the similarities go on and on.  The primary difference, though, is that the Battle Royale game is seen as a military training necessity for Greater East Asia, where as the Hunger Games are specifically meant to be a reminder to the districts of how the Capitol punishes disobedience and disloyalty.  Slim difference.  That being said, the primary idea (which has been retold many times by many authors in many different forms, by now) is brilliant and original.  Although the author does not mention it, it would be hard not to see some minor influence, at least, from The Lord of the Flies.  The study of human nature, group dynamics, and survival instincts by witnessing the actions of teenagers isolated on an inescapable island – of course the influence is there; however, the important distinction is that these children did not land on the island by mistake, they were kidnapped and are being manipulated by their government and their elders.  This says just as much about society and politics as the microcosm of Golding’s island did.  The influence of action films and rock music, too are clear – both in the themes of the story and in its structure; for example, the main character and two main supporting characters (one who aids the main character, the other who is hunting him) are directly inspired by the movie Terminator 2.  The questioning of blind obedience to authority, the themes of oppression, fear, trust, isolation, and the dangers of totalitarian governments and violent Nationalism are all explored and effective.


Suggested Reading for:
Age Level: High School +
Interest: Pop Culture, Youth Violence, Survival of the Fittest, Fight to the Death, Action, Humanity, Politics, Society, Japanese fiction, Dystopia.


Quotes:

“And so his choice to reduce the numbers of “the enemy” as efficiently as possible wasn’t motivated by rational thoughts but instead by a deeper, primal fear of death.”

“Please live. Talk, think, act. And sometimes listen to music . . . look at paintings, allow yourself to be moved.  Laugh a lot, and at times, cry. And if you find a wonderful girl, then you go for her and love her.”

“It’s not a bad thing to be loved.”

“Their two bodies danced in the air beyond the cliff, their hands still clasped together, the black sea under them.”

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “Review: Battle Royale by Koushun Takami

  1. I haven’t read the book yet, but I saw the movie and it kiiind of sounds like it’s slightly better than the book, even! (Shocking concept, I know!) I watched it not long after The Hunger Games came out, and I was just like… DAMN, I can’t believe how much better than THG that was. And I like The Hunger Games!

    So basically, I want to read this. A lot.

    • It was definitely a positive experience, but it didn’t quite live up to my expectations. I think, on an originality and literary level, it’s probably slightly better than The Hunger Games – but as far as being more believable and serious, I think THG has the edge.

      • Hmmm….I disagree with you. I feel that BR is far better than THG and more realistic. More grit and many more layers – themes and such. It has been a while since I read the book so I would have to go back to my review to be more specific. Granted, I do not read books with the same kind of critical eye as yours though.

      • Agree to disagree, then. 🙂 I feel the idea for BR is brilliant, but the delivery is a bit over-the-top and “slasher-esque” (similar to, say, the movie Kill Bill – lots of killing for the sake of killing). The author admits as such, in his final interview on the book – he said, originally, he did not intend to take the book seriously, but the gravity of the story came to him over the course of many edits and revisions – I think that early comic/anime feel still comes through, though (unfortunately). Granted, that genre has quite a lot of fans – so, for them, I think this book would be a huge hit.

        In The Hunger Games, there’s a solid history behind the games and why the districts fear rebelling. That being said, I do agree that, overall, BR has a slight edge to The Hunger Games (and that it is more original, considering it’s impossible to believe that Collins didn’t get quite a bit of her inspiration from this one).

        Also, to be fair, I’m almost ignoring Mockingjay from my opinion of The Hunger Games, because that third book nearly ruined the series, in my opinion.

  2. I’ve been wanting to read this book for years, but I just haven’t gotten around to it yet. I’m glad to hear that the characterization is good, and that you enjoyed the book overall, even if it didn’t quite meet your expectations. I know this book has been getting a lot of renewed interest because of The Hunger Games, and I have to admit…I’m interested in seeing the parallels myself!

  3. I’ve wanted to read this book since I saw the movie many years ago. Glad to hear that characterization is good, and that the background is given.

    • I’m actually watching the movie this weekend – I’ve owned the book for almost a decade. My partner saw the movie pop-up on Netflix and thought it was interesting, I told him I had the book, so he read it and then forced me to read it so we could watch the movie together. Lol

  4. A copy of Battle Royale made its way into my hands recently, so I’m highly anxious to start it once I get through my huge stack of library books. It sounds like the characterization is mostly well-grounded, then? Regardless, I’m still excited to read this one, and I have to see the movie afterward!

    There’s so much talk about the similarities between Takami’s novel and The Hunger Games. It will be interesting for me to read since I unexpectedly enjoyed TGH, but I almost wonder if my opinion of Collins’ series will change after this.

  5. This is one that I’ve been meaning to read for a while, but it always seems to get pushed to the back by all the other books that I have on my massive reading list. I definitely want to make the time to read it some day, though. Great review!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s